HomeMy WebLinkAbout05/18/2015�
BAKERSFIELD
/�'/ StP�vPi TP��t;a�
Staff: Steve Teglia
Assistant City Manager
Committee M
Terry Maxwell
Jacquie Sulliv
Chris Parlier
REGULAR MEETING OF THE
LEGISLATIVE AND LITIGATION COMMITTEE
Monday, May 18, 2015
12:00 p.m.
City Hall North - Conference Room A
1600 Truxtun Avenue
Bakersfield, CA 93301
The meeting was called to order at 12:00 p.m.
1. ROLL CALL
Committee members:
Councilmember, Terry Maxwell, Chair
Councilmember, Jacquie Sullivan
Councilmember, Chris Parlier
City Staff:
Alan Tandy, City Manager
Steve Teglia, Assistant City Manager
Christopher Gerry, Administrative Analyst - City Manager's Office
Virginia Gennaro, City Attorney
Josh Rudnick, Deputy City Attorney
Richard Iger, Associate City Attorney
Greg Williamson, Chief of Police
Lieutenant Jeremy Grimes, Bakersfield Police Department
Phil Burns, Building Director
Additional Attendees:
Kim Schaefer, Bakersfield Association of Realtors
A A _ .__ I_ _ .._ _ t 1I_ _ A A _ _I : _.
Legislative and Litigation Comr
May 18, 2015 - Agenda S�
4. NEW BUSINESS
A. Discussion reaardinq the Ordinance relatina to Abandoned Buildin
City Attorney Gennaro stated that this topic was referred for Commit
by Councilmember Maxwell. She pointed out that a memorandum
Attorney's Office and the Community Development Department wc
the meeting packet.
Building Director Burns presented a slide show that detailed buildin�
and in other parts of the City that are vacant, boarded up, or have
by vagrants. There are ordinances and Municipal Code sections
various property maintenance violations such as weeds, debri.
vegetation, broken windows, deteriorated facades and walkwa
section, 8.80, that specifically focuses on abatement and publ
Examples were shown of some vacant buildings that are not in top c
do not rise to the level of being in violation of the Code.
The administrative process begins with verification that there is a
seven-day written notice to abate the nuisance is mailed to the pro�
the address listed on the tax rolls. A re-inspection is then performec
has been no action, a ten-day notice for a hearing is mailed to
owner. Subsequent to the hearing, the property owner has ten dc
the decision before bids are issued and received for abatement
require an additional five days to ensure mail is received. Aftei
another hearing is held that leads to action by the City Council to pl�
on the property for recovery of abatement costs.
A comparison with other cities was done during the time of the ho�
that revealed Bakersfield's process regarding foreclosed homes wa<
the other cities surveyed. Staff decided at that time to partner with
Realtors and continue with the existing process. A follow-up survey o1
cities was performed in response to Councilmember Maxwell'
determine what other types of ordinances to address vacant buildir
place, and the results were quite varied.
Committee member Parlier asked if an administrative process
another tool to gain compliance.
Building Director Burns said that it could help, depending on how it w�
City Attorney Gennaro said that it could be an additional tool; ai
Council desires to pursue it, staff would look at it in a broader contex
h���i��i�r +hrv+ +h�r� ��i�i ilrJ hrv�i� +� l-�� �vr� �r�f�r��rv��r�+ rv���hrvr�i
Legislative and Litigation Comr
May 18, 2015 - Agenda S�
Committee Chair Maxwell asked if an ordinance could be drafted th
downtown area only.
Deputy City Attorney Rudnick said that while staff's efforts could
downtown area, any ordinance should be applicable citywide.
Committee Chair Maxwell asked if it was possible to require downt
owners whose businesses had an alcove to construct a metal acco
restrict access to the alcove, such as what exists at Chester Ave
Street.
Deputy City Attorney Rudnick said that it could be added as a
however, general conditions would allow more flexibility tc
compliance. Additional requirements could be to register the vac
and specify an amount of time to renovate, rent or sell the pi
Francisco has a new ordinance whereby commercial property ov�
pay a registration fee within a predetermined amount of time that
became vacant, and then show proof that efforts are being mac
property or that they are actively doing something with it.
Committee Chair Maxwell stated that his goal is to generate an or
would be persuasive enough to motivate owners of vacant buildinc
the building or perhaps sell it to another entity. The ordinance �
property owners from abandoning the buildings. He noted that the :
ordinance related to commercial properties, and asked if thE
requirement would be different if the property was residential.
Building Director Burns said that a residential requirement would k
and he recommended that any requirements be specific. He add
still has to be a mechanism to enforce any constraints listed in such a
Committee Chair Maxwell said that he would like to pursue a strc
ordinance for Committee discussion. If this is not possible, then
should be explored to reach the same conclusion. The downtown
revitalized.
City Manager Tandy reported that staff recently developed a conc
economic incentive zones with the goal of revitalizing distressec
growth is captured that could be reinvested to further enhance the 1
downtown area is one such zone being considered. This would be
based program, rather than one that is centered on code enforcem
YY1CyYlV (�f tilP. SC7f"YIP. YPCI IItC �'C'iYl i�P. P.Xt'�P.C'tP.Ci Fl li'ti1P.f' f'P.flf'1P.PY1P.Ylt IC Y1P.E
Legislative and Litigation Comr
May 18, 2015 - Agenda S�
downtown and relocate a portion of their staff there. Or, if parcels c
to ensure adequate parking, perhaps a medical facility might be
expanding in the area. He requested that staff provide follow-up inf�
future Committee meeting.
Committee member Sullivan asked staff to continue monitoring sir
other municipalities, such as San Francisco. She said she was encou
information provided by City Manager Tandy and staff.
City Attorney Gennaro and Building Director Burns reviewec
enforcement notification process with her. The process used is c
established by State law. If the process leads to a decision by the C
lien is placed on the property and remains in place until either the p
or brought into compliance.
City Manager Tandy asked what percentage of properties are
compliance following the first notification versus the amount of I
placed.
Building Director Burns said that an estimate of 7-10�0 of the cc
opened result in liens.
City Manager Tandy stated and Building Director Burns concurred t
certain extenuating situations that lead to what may seem as a Iac4
the property.
Assistant City Manager Teglia added that there are different levels �
actions, some to recoup costs that the City incurred at the beg
process, up to and including the recovery of costs for abatement.
Committee member Sullivan said that the downtown is looking bettei
Committee Chair Maxwell replied that certain sections are looking
businesses are opening, and more people are enthused and enco�
downtown. However, the concern is the amount of abandoned buil�
not being maintained. The only recourse may be to find someone
purchase those properties and restore them.
Committee member Sullivan noted that the owner has to be willing
Committee Chair Maxwell said that once staff provides additional inf
C'nmmittPP ��n �li��� i�� �II r����ihlP nr�ti�n�
Legislative and Litigation Comr
May 18, 2015 - Agenda S�
5. DEFERRED BUSINESS
A. Update on Bath Salts and Spice Legislation
City Attorney Gennaro stated that a memorandum on this topic wc
the meeting packet. The item is back before the Committee at tl
Committee member Parlier.
At the last Committee meeting, staff presented a PowerPoint that
definitions of bath salts and spice. It was reported at that time thc
due to go to the Public Safety Committee on May 12, 2015. Sub.
unknown reasons, the author of the bill pulled it from consideratior
reintroduced and ultimately passes, possession of bath salts and
illegal, and the definitions of both substances will be enhanced. Ad
penalties for possession and sale will scale upwards, with a first offe
infraction, the second, a misdemeanor, etc.
The options are to direct staff to investigate the basis for pulling the k
back to Committee, or to draft an ordinance for review that would i
to possess either substance. If an ordinance is drafted, staff woulc
enhanced definitions and the proposed language of SB-139.
Committee member Parlier asked if such an ordinance would prc
tool for law enforcement to deal with the problems.
Police Chief Williamson said that it would; however, quite often a wa
be obtained, and then there is a concern about whether or not
could positively identify a substance as being bath salts or spice.
Lieutenant Grimes added that it is unknown at this time how any
might be challenged in court and what hurdles may exist in
compounds.
Committee member Parlier asked if the ordinance that was adopte
of Taft covers the varying chemical compounds of both bath salts an
City Attorney Gennaro replied that of all of the cities that were su
had ordinances that contained the expanded definitions that are pr
139. If the Committee elects to proceed with an ordinance, she
including the enhanced definitions.
Legislative and Litigation Comr
May 18, 2015 - Agenda S�
City Attorney Gennaro stated that while the language in SB-139 may
will start with the existing language.
Committee member Parlier recommended flexibility, and that the i
Committee for discussion.
City Attorney Gennaro said the first draft will be ready for discussion i
next Committee meeting on June 22, 2015. The existing defin
incorporated, and language will be included that indicates it may
relative to any future changes in the Health and Safety Code. She
the motion is for staff to draft an ordinance that would make the sa
and possession of bath salts and spice illegal.
Committee member Sullivan asked if one substance was worse than
City Attorney Gennaro replied that both cause very bizarre a
behavior in people, and the effects are different for each individuc
on the dosage.
Committee Chair Maxwell said it would be prudent to bring it back t
to discuss the language before it is presented to the City Council. I
the motion.
The motion was unanimously approved.
6. COMMITTEE COMMENTS
Committee member Sullivan asked if there is an update on the squatter issu�
City Attorney Gennaro said that, subsequent to the discussion at the Marc
meeting, she believed follow-up information had been provided on this tc
review her file to verify that it was distributed and then talk with Commi
Sullivan about the topic. No additional information has been received by st
7. ADJOURNMENT
The meeting adjourned at 12:52 p.m.