HomeMy WebLinkAbout10.20.20 HPC Agenda packet
CITY OF BAKERSFIELD HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION
MEETING OF OCTOBER 20, 2020 AGENDA MEETING 4:00 P.M
Development Services Building 1715 Chester Avenue, Bakersfield California First Floor Conference Room
SPECIAL NOTICE Public Participation and Accessibility On March 18, 2020, Governor Gavin Newsom issued Executive Order N-29-20, which includes
a waiver of Brown Act provisions requiring physical presence of the Commission or the public
in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. Based on guidance from the California Governor’s Office and Department of Public Health, as well as the County Health Officer, in order to minimize the potential spread of the COVID-19
virus, the City of Bakersfield hereby provides notice that as a result of the declared federal,
state, and local health emergencies, and in light of the Governor’s order, the following adjustments have been made:
1. The meeting scheduled for October 20, 2020, at 4:00 p.m. at the Development Services Building, 1715 Chester Avenue, Bakersfield California, First Floor Conference
Room, will have limited public access to preserve social distancing.
2. Consistent with the Executive Order, Commission members may elect to attend the meeting telephonically or via Zoom meeting app and to participate in the meeting to the same extent as if they were physically present. 3. The public may participate in each meeting and address the Historic Preservation
Commission as follows:
• If you wish to comment on a specific agenda item, submit your comment via email to the Economic and Community Development Department at ecdc@bakersfieldcity.us no later than 1:00 p.m. prior to the Commission
meeting. Please clearly indicate which agenda item number your comment
pertains to.
• If you wish to make a general public comment not related to a specific agenda
item, submit your comment via email to the Economic & Community Development
Department at ecdc@bakersfieldcity.us no later than 1:00 p.m. prior to the Commission meeting.
A. ROLL CALL B. PUBLIC STATEMENTS
C. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
1. Minutes of the February 18, 2020, meeting for approval. 2. Minutes of the September 15, 2020, meeting for approval.
D. CLOSED SESSION None
E. CORRESPONDENCE
None F. PUBLIC HEARINGS
None G. REPORTS
None H. OLD BUSINESS 1. Current Historic Preservation Commission Committee Members
a. Ad Hoc Committee on Mills Act
b. Cultural Resource and Architectural Committee c. Ordinance and By-laws Committee Recommendation: Receive and file. 2. Mills Act Letter of Support Recommendation: Review and discuss the draft support letter. 3. Historic Preservation Commission Education and Outreach Updates
Recommendations: Staff recommends discussion. I. NEW BUSINESS 1. Historic Preservation Commission Consultation Letter – Jastro Park Stage
Restoration. Recommendation: Staff recommends review and submission of the comment letter to the City of Bakersfield Recreation and Parks Department.
J. COMMISSIONER STATEMENTS K. ADJOURNMENT
Respectfully submitted,
Christopher Boyle,
Development Services Director
If anyone wants more information on any of these agenda items, call Cecelia Griego, Economic Development
Principal Planner; Economic & Community Development Department at (661) 326-3788.
S:\EDCD_Shared\ED Projects\ED HPC\HPC Meetings\2020\HPC 10.20.20\10.20.20 HPC Agenda.docx
CITY OF BAKERSFIELD HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING OF FEBRUARY 18, 2020 MINUTES
Chair Stussy called the regular meeting of the Historic Preservation Commission to order
on Tuesday, February 18, 2020, at 4:00 p.m. at the First Floor Conference Room, 1715 Chester Avenue, Development Services Building. Roll call was as follows:
MEMBERS PRESENT: Cathy Butler
Stephen Humphreys Stephen Montgomery
Susan Stussy
MEMBERS ABSENT: Cheryl Long
STAFF PRESENT: Cecelia Griego
Joshua Rudnick
Christina Oleson
Christine Gutierrez
Jason Cater
PUBLIC STATEMENTS:
None APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
1. Motion to approve minutes from the November 19, 2019 meeting. Minutes approved: Motion made by Commissioner Montgomery; Second by
Commissioner Butler. APPROVED: All Ayes CLOSED SESSION:
None CORRESPONDENCE:
The Commission received a request for information from Kern County General Services on Hart Park Peacock House. Commissioner Montgomery stated that he is in the process
of providing information to the County. PUBLIC HEARINGS:
None
REPORTS:
None
OLD BUSINESS:
1. Selection of Historic Preservation Commission Committee Members:
a. The Commission voted to appoint Commissioner Butler and Humphreys to the
Cultural Resources and Architectural Committee: Chair Stussy nominated and
the Commission voted all ayes.
b. The Commission voted to appoint Commissioner Butler and Humphreys to the
Ad Hoc Committee on Mills Act: Chair Stussy nominated and the Commission
voted all ayes.
2. Mills Act Letter of Support
a. Commission was presented with a re-draft of the template letter.
b. Commissioner Butler made mention of a scheduled meeting at the Guild
House on March 2 at 4:00 regarding the Mills Act to engage interest from
neighborhoods to form a district. The letters would be provided for signatures
on petition and to answer questions. Also at 5:30, a property owners meeting (Mixer) would be held at the Guild House.
NEW BUSINESS 1. Historic Plaque installation on the Moronet Building
a. Initially, Ken Hooper spoke with the Manager of the Moronet Building on the situation with the installation. It was stated that the owner of the building
did not want the plaque installed on the building, it was preferred to be
installed in the lobby. At this time, 1.5 years later, the response from the
owner is the same. We are still waiting for permission to install the plaque
on the building.
b. The name of the owner is needed to approach personally. City can assist
by researching the owner’s name and contact Ken Hooper with the
information.
2. Historic Preservation Commission Education and Outreach Updates
a. A new tablecloth will be ordered for events. Logo has been cleaned up for
a brighter stamp. It will be black with white lettering and logo. Should be
available in May.
b. The website is now current with all updates. A Mills Act link with basic
information has been added to the website.
c. Name badges for new commissioners will be ordered with the tablecloth.
d. Education and training on historic preservation topics for Commissioners
and City staff will be available through webinars in the FY20/21. They can
take place in the Development Services first floor large conference room. e. Updates to the Rehabilitate Bakersfield Right Handbook: Commissioner
Montgomery will continue on the revision and will be giving the Commission reports on the progress.
COMMISSION STATEMENTS:
None
ADJOURNMENT:
The meeting adjourned at 4:45 p.m. by Commissioner Stussy.
CITY OF BAKERSFIELD HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 15, 2020 MINUTES
Chair Stussy called the regular meeting of the Historic Preservation Commission to order
on Tuesday, September 15, 2020, at 4:05 p.m. at the First Floor Conference Room, 1715 Chester Avenue, Development Services Building, with Commissioner Stussy, Montgomery,
Butler, and members of City staff joining via Zoom. Roll call was as follows:
MEMBERS PRESENT: Cathy Butler Stephen Humphreys
Stephen Montgomery
Susan Stussy
MEMBERS ABSENT: None
STAFF PRESENT: Cecelia Griego
Joshua Rudnick
Christina Oleson
Jason Cater
Brianna Carrier
Diane Hoover
Stuart Patterson
Fidel Gonzalez
Frank Hinojosa
PUBLIC STATEMENTS:
None APPROVAL OF MINUTES: 1. Motion to approve minutes from the November 19, 2019 meeting.
Minutes Postponed: Motion to approve was made by Commissioner Butler; no second as Commissioner Stussy noted an error in the minutes pertaining to the
membership of the Committees developed at the February 18th, 2020 meeting. Staff informed the commission that they will review meeting minutes from February
18th, 2020, make updates as needed, and subsequently submit the minutes for review and approval at the subsequent meeting.
CLOSED SESSION:
None
CORRESPONDENCE:
None
PUBLIC HEARINGS:
None REPORTS:
None OLD BUSINESS:
None
NEW BUSINESS
1. Review of Jastro Park Stage Restoration Project
a. Cecelia Griego, Economic Development Principal Planner for the City of
Bakersfield Community and Economic Development and Fidel Gonzalez, Parks Construction and Facilities Planner for the City of Bakersfield
Recreation and Parks Department, gave a presentation on the proposed Jastro Park Stage Restoration Project and requested input from the
Commission on the undertaking. Generally, the project includes aesthetic enhancements and ADA improvements. After the presentation, the
Commission offered the following comments: a. ADA Access Ramps: ADA access ramps should include components
that deter skateboarders from using the ramps. Also, ADA access improvements should be designed to minimize the impact to the
existing structure. b. Color Scheme: The paint color chosen for the project should match
the structures original green palette. Staff commented that the theater was painted blue about three years ago as part of a series
of enhancements undertaken at Jastro Park to correspond with the
completion of the Westside Parkway, however the original color
could certainly be incorporated into the proposed renovations. The
Commission recommended that old plans and photos be
researched to, as much as possible, correlate the color with the
original scheme. Additionally, it was recommended that staff chip
away at the current paint coat to identifying the original paint layer.
c. Original Structure Components: Original structural components,
such as the balusters, granite stairs on both ends of the stage, and
railing should be preserved to protect the facilities historic integrity.
d. Commissioner Butler voiced her support for the undertaking, stating
that the project aligns with the 30-year anniversary of when the All-
American Celebration was held at Jastro Park.
Motion: The Historic Preservation Commission should offer its services as a
partner to enhance and protect this architectural treasure.
Motion: Commissioner Butler, Second: Commissioner Montgomery
Vote: All Ayes.
COMMISSION STATEMENTS:
Commissioner Stussy requested a quick review of items from the February 18th, 2020
Agenda items to check in on where things left off. The following items were discussed:
a. Peacock House – Hart Park: Commissioner Montgomery reported that the
property will be an educational center focused on informing the public of the
area’s history. The County is receiving a grant from the State to fund the projects
restoration.
b. Mills Act Support Letter – Commissioner Stussy requested that staff continue where
we left off with the support letter so we can prepare to circulate a letter for
community support. Commissioner Butler supported the continued efforts on the
letter in order to move the Mills Act program forward.
c. Historic District Formation: At this time, the effort to form an Historic District can be
placed on hold due to the pandemic.
d. Moronet Building Plaque – Staff informed the Commission that they contacted the owner of the building regarding the plaque. The owner informed them that he is
not interested in putting the plaque on the outside of the building due to concerns about vandalism. Commissioner Stussy requested that the owner of the building
be approached again to discuss putting the plaque on the exterior of the building rather than on the inside.
ADJOURNMENT:
The meeting adjourned at 5:00 p.m. by Commissioner Stussy.
A D M I N I S T R A T I V E R E P O R T
Meeting Date: October 20, 2020 Agenda Section: Old Business Agenda Item: H - 1
TO: Historic Preservation Commission
FROM: Economic & Community Development Department
DATE: October 14, 2020
SUBJECT: Current Historic Preservation Commission Committee Members a. Ad Hoc Committee on Mills Act
b. Cultural Resource and Architectural Committee c. Ordinance and By-Laws Committee
RECOMMENDATION:
Recommendation is to receive and file. BACKGROUND:
Due to the confusion on committee appointments, staff reviewed the past meeting minutes and found the current committee appointments to be as follows:
• Ad Hoc Committee on Mills Act: Commissioners Cathy Butler and Stephen
Humphreys
• Cultural Resource and Architectural Committee: Commissioners Cathy Butler and
Stephen Humphreys
• Ordinance and By-laws Committee: Commissioners Stephen Montgomery and
Susan Stussy
Due to new commission appointments, the Commission discussed updating
appointments to the two standing committees, the Cultural Resource and Architectural
Committee and the Ordinance and By-laws Committee, and requested the formation of
an Ad Hoc Committee on the Mills Act.
At the November 19, 2019 Historic Preservation Commission meeting, the commission
voted in the Ordinance and By-laws Committee, and chose to delay the appointments
of the other two committees until a full commission is present.
At the February 18, 2020 Commission meeting, the Commission voted and approved the appointments of Commissioner Humphreys and Commissioner Butler to the Cultural
Resource and Architectural Committee and the Mills Act Ad Hoc Committee. The Committee on the Mills Act will provide guidance on the formation of a Mills Act program
and assist with gathering community support from eligible property owners.
S:\EDCD_Shared\ED Projects\ED HPC\HPC Meetings\2020\HPC 10.20.20\Historic Preservation Committees.docx
A D M I N I S T R A T I V E R E P O R T
Meeting Date: October 20, 2020 Agenda Section: Old Business Agenda Item: H - 2
TO: Historic Preservation Commission
FROM: Economic and Community Development Department
DATE: October 13, 2020
SUBJECT: Mills Act Support Letter RECOMMENDATION:
Recommendation: Review and discuss the draft support letter.
BACKGROUND:
At the November 19, 2019 meeting, a draft of the Mills Act support letter was presented
for discussion. Subsequent to the meeting and at the direction of the Commission, City staff sent an electronic version to Commissioners to review and modify. Since that time,
comments and edits have been received from Commissioner Stussy and Commissioner Montgomery. At the September 15, 2020 Historic Preservation Commission meeting, staff
was directed to bring the current template letter of support for a Mills Act program to the
Commission for review. A draft of the letter is attached.
S:\EDCD_Shared\ED Projects\ED HPC\HPC Meetings\2020\HPC 10.20.20\Mills Act Admin.docx
Date
Honorable Mayor Karen Goh Members of the Bakersfield City Council
1501 Truxtun Ave. Bakersfield CA 93301
Re: 1234 5th St., Bakersfield CA 93300
Honorable Mayor and City Council:
My property has been designated by the City as a significant cultural, historical or
architectural resource. With my interest in preserving our built heritage and contributing
to an attractive community streetscape, I believe, with the adoption of a local Mills Act
program, the City would facilitate and encourage owners of properties with historical
provenance to apply for and use the benefits of the provisions of the Mills Act to enhance
and preserve their properties and contribute to the revitalization of their neighborhood.
Since the Mills Act was signed into law in 1972 it has, throughout the state, facilitated
much valuable preservation of our built heritage. Communities that have adopted the
Act have enjoyed increased property values by nearby non-historic properties along with
the registered historic properties.
The Mills Act authorized local initiatives that foster the preservation of residential neighborhoods and the revitalization of downtown commercial districts. Enacted in 1972,
the Mills Act legislation grants participating local governments the authority to enter into contracts with owners of qualified historic properties who actively participate in the
restoration and maintenance of their historic properties while receiving property tax relief.
With the benefit of the provisions of the Mills Act, my property would contribute to preserving the multifaceted cultural and built fabric of our community with the historic
complementing the new.
It’s my desire, in using the provisions of the Mills Act, to maintain and preserve the historic elements of my property. This will preserve and increase an attractive streetscape while
keeping an element of our history among us. Thank you for your consideration of this matter.
Sincerely,
A D M I N I S T R A T I V E R E P O R T
Meeting Date: October 20, 2020 Agenda Section: Old Business Agenda Item: H - 3
TO: Historic Preservation Commission
FROM: Economic and Community Development Department
DATE: October 13, 2020
SUBJECT: Historic Preservation Commission Education and Outreach Updates RECOMMENDATION:
Recommendation: Staff recommends discussion.
BACKGROUND:
Commissioner requested items related to Commission education and public outreach
efforts for discussion:
- Updates to the Rehabilitate Bakersfield Right Handbook - Website updates
- Distribution of brochures: Downtown Bakersfield Plaque Walking Tour, Stepping
into the Past, and others
S:\EDCD_Shared\ED Projects\ED HPC\HPC Meetings\2020\HPC 2.18.20\2.18.20 Education and Outreach
Update.docx
A D M I N I S T R A T I V E R E P O R T
Meeting Date: October 20, 2020 Agenda Section: New Business Agenda Item: I - 1
TO: Historic Preservation Commission
FROM: Economic and Community Development Department
DATE: October 14, 2020
SUBJECT: Historic Preservation Commission Consultation Letter – Jastro Park Stage
Restoration
RECOMMENDATION:
Recommendation: Staff recommends review and submission of the consultation letter to
the City of Bakersfield Recreation and Parks Department.
BACKGROUND:
In accordance with powers and duties in Bakersfield Municipal Code 15.172.040, the
Bakersfield Historic Preservation Commission is authorized to review and correspond with
City departments to matters as they relate to the cultural resources of the community.
Within the scope of this authority, the City of Bakersfield Recreation and Parks
Department presented at the September 15, 2020 Commission meeting to request input
and recommendation from your Commission on an undertaking being considered for
the Jastro Park Stage.
Staff from the Recreation and Parks and Economic and Community Development
Departments presented on the history and the different components of the project’s restoration. After the presentation concluded, your Commission voted unanimously to
submit a letter and offer its services as a partner to enhance and protect this architectural treasure.
Attached is a draft letter summarizing the recommendations of the Commission for
review and submission to the City of Bakersfield’s Recreation and Parks Department.
1 7 1 5 C h e s t e r A v e n u e, B a k e r s f i e l d, C a l i f o r n i a 9 3 3 0 1
October 14, 2020
To: Diane Hoover Director of Recreation and Parks
City of Bakersfield
1600 Truxtun Avenue, 3rd Floor
Bakersfield, CA 93301
Re: Jastro Park Stage Restoration Project
Dear Ms. Hoover:
Thank you for presenting the Bakersfield Historic Preservation Commission the opportunity
to provide input as the Recreation and Parks Department considers renovations and ADA improvements to the Jastro Park Stage. We look forward to continue offering feedback
and to work in partnership to enhance and protect this architectural treasure.
The Commission recommends the following considerations:
- Original structural components, such as balusters, granite stairs on both ends of the
stage, railing, and any ornamental design should be preserved to protect the facilities
historic integrity.
- If ADA access ramps are installed as part of the project, they should minimize their
impact to the integrity of the original structure. Removing original items, such as railing,
balusters, and ornaments should be avoided when possible.
- The paint color chosen for the project should match the structures original color
palette. We recommend that old plans and photos be researched to correlate the new coat with the original scheme. Additionally, we recommend your staff chip away at the structure’s current paint layer to identify its original.
- Cement blocks appear to have replaced balusters on the structures western railing as
a result of vandalism. We recommend consideration be given to replacing the cement
blocks with balusters which match the original structure to help restore the structures
historic character.
The Commission thanks you for the opportunity to provide its input. Jastro Park is a part of the history of our community and is a valuable cultural resource. We strongly support this
undertaking and efforts to restore and preserve this historic character of this amenity.
Sincerely,
Susan Stussy, Chair
Bakersfield Historic Preservation Commission
BAKER STREET
PUBLIC LIBRARY
Established 1915
Attachment A – Jastro Park Stage Historic Photos